Review: Falling for You by Lisa Schroeder

Falling for YouBy Lisa Schroeder

Publisher: Simon Pulse
Publication Date: January 1, 2013
Genre: Young Adult Contemporary
Source: Purchased

Rae’s always dreamed of dating a guy like Nathan. He’s nothing like her abusive stepfather—in other words, he’s sweet. But the closer they get, the more Nathan wants of her time, of her love, of her…and the less she wants to give.

As Rae’s affection for Nathan turns to fear, she leans on her friend Leo for support. With Leo, she feels lighter, happier. And possessive Nathan becomes jealous. He’s not about to let her go. And with danger following her every move, Rae must fight for the life and love she deserves if she’s going to survive.

Goodreads Summary
Add to your shelf

Okay, you know I did it. I oohed and aahed over that cover and it caught my eye long before the synopsis did. I’m so ashamed (no I’m not). Then I went and sat at the adult table and read the blurb, checked out the author and saw that she wasn’t writing this in her trademark all-verse style and knew I had to read it even if it wasn’t the New Adult book that it looked like (confusing covers). The freaky abusive boyfriend/poor girl storyline is one that can be tricky to do without it turning into something resembling a tabloid movie, but Schroeder pulled off a pretty good, complex story with one heck of a surprise at the end.

[Read more...]

Share on Tumblr

The Day Before

The Day BeforeBy Lisa Schroeder

Publisher: Simon Pulse
Publication Date: June 28, 2011
Genre: Young Adult Romance
Source: Publisher

Amber’s life is spinning out of control. All she wants is to turn up the volume on her iPod until all of the demands of family and friends fade away. So she sneaks off to the beach to spend a day by herself.Then Amber meets Cade. Their attraction is instant, and Amber can tell he’s also looking for an escape. Together they decide to share a perfect day: no pasts, no fears, no regrets.

The more time that Amber spends with Cade, the more she’s drawn to him. And the more she’s troubled by his darkness. Because Cade’s not just living in the now—he’s living each moment like it’s his last.

Goodreads Summary

The day before her life will change forever, Amber decides to run away and spend the time alone, not thinking about anything more than the moment.  Not long after she arrives at the beach, she meets Cade, a boy who’s come there for the same reason – he has his own life-altering path to take the next day and he’d like to spend this day just pretending nothing else exists.  The two spend the entire day together at the beach, discovering how many things they have in common and as they gradually reveal their secrets to each other, falling in love.

I found myself really struggling to get through this despite its remarkably short length.  The entire book is written in free-form verse style, interspersed with short letters to and from Amber.  I was reading this on my Nook and with each double-spaced short line taking up an average of half of the screen – there were 320 total pages – I was able to read this in about an hour or so.  It may be physically easier to read in paperback form because you won’t be flipping pages so often, but that’s only one of the problems I had.

I don’t have anything against stories told in verse form.  I think when written well they can be emotionally stirring, evocative and memorable.  I give credit to the author for trying to tell her stories in such a unique way (her three earlier books, Far From YouChasing Brooklyn, and I Heart You, You Haunt Me are also told in verse) and there’s a dreamy disconnected feeling to this that seems to suit Amber’s mood.  That disconnect extends to the story though – the verse isn’t linear long enough to ever delve that deeply into anything.  Rather than feeling like a strong, brave way to tell the story, the use of verse felt more like a way to write the story without having to do the dirty work of going all the way to the bones of the characters.

At this point it’s probably a bit like piling on, but while I really was irritated with the style of writing and was thinking often that I’d wished the author would have taken some time and written this like a novel, I probably still wouldn’t have loved it although I’d have had less to gripe about.  Amber’s situation that she was running from was one of those “ripped from the headlines” type.  You’d think that would be enough for one story but Cade’s was one suitable for a made for television movie.  Toss in their insta-love, a romantic day at the beach, constant lyric and movie references and comparisons to their situations – are you imagining a soundtrack yet?  I love happily-ever-afters and romance but this was over the top even for me.  What teenage guy in 2011 knows about the scenes from a John Cusak movie from the 80′s that I’m pretty sure isn’t a cult classic?

My Summary: This book was fraught with problems for me from its style to the overabundance of drama in a relatively shallow story.  I kept seeing flashes of good things that made me wish for more – a lovely turn of phrase, a hint of a story twist – but then I’d turn the page and it would vanish.  At the end, this felt more like the outline of a script for an ABC Family movie of the week than a book.

My Rating: D+

Barbara

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Share on Tumblr